Robin half-space perturbations: a credited dimension-dependent answer to AIM Problem 1.4
Read the paper (PDF) · Download PDF · Supporting ZIP · Zenodo record
Plain-English explanation · Read on this page · Collaboration
Abstract
We give a negative answer to the literal dimension-unrestricted wording of AIM Problem 1.4 on attractive Robin bound states under compact half-space perturbations. A nonzero smooth graph in R⁴, specified explicitly, has spectrum [−1,∞) at Robin strength one. In contrast, every connected, smooth, nontrivial compact half-space perturbation in ambient dimension two or three binds below the flat threshold at every positive strength, including overhangs and compact boundary components. Every compact Lipschitz graph in dimension at least four has no below-threshold spectrum at sufficiently weak strength. This is a credited exposition of standard mechanisms: Exner–Minakov already proved planar binding and used the exponential/Stokes normal-defect argument; the graph absence conclusion also follows from the established Hoang–Hundertmark–Richter–Vugalter bound after the explicit geometric comparison supplied here. We give both that implication and a self-contained Hardy–trace certificate. Historical priority of the exact remaining geometric formulations, novelty, worldwide open status and independent discovery remain unresolved. Extensive AI assistance was used; this note is unrefereed.
The idea in plain English
A local change to a flat boundary can trap a Robin state in two or three dimensions. In four or more dimensions, a compact graph deformation can instead leave no spectrum below the flat threshold when the attraction is weak enough.
The precise result
For the attractive Robin form q[u]=∫Ω|∇u|²−β∫∂Ω|u|², β>0, every connected smooth nontrivial compact perturbation of a half-space in ambient dimension 2 or 3 has an eigenvalue below −β². For every compactly supported Lipschitz graph deformation in ambient dimension at least 4, the spectrum is [−β²,∞) for all sufficiently small positive β. In R⁴, f(x)=exp(−1/(1−|x|²))/100 for |x|<1 and zero otherwise gives spectrum [−1,∞) at β=1.
How the argument works
An exponential ground-state identity exposes a positive boundary-normal defect. Low-dimensional cutoff functions make that defect produce a bound state. In higher dimensions, Hardy and trace estimates control the defect instead; a second route uses the established massive-relativistic eigenvalue bound after an explicit geometric comparison.
Scope
The negative answer concerns the literal dimension-unrestricted wording of AIM Problem 1.4. Low-dimensional binding permits overhangs and compact boundary components. Higher-dimensional absence is proved for compact graphs at sufficiently weak strength; it does not classify arbitrary nongraph perturbations, give one nonzero graph absent at every strength, or exclude embedded eigenvalues. The displayed example is fixed at β=1; for any other prescribed β, its amplitude may be chosen smaller.
Background and prior work
AIM Problem 1.4 asks the binding question. Exner and Minakov established planar binding and used the normal-defect argument. The high-dimensional comparison uses the published Hoang–Hundertmark–Richter–Vugalter bound. Frank and Laptev give the related flat Robin reduction.
Status and AI use
Unrefereed preprint. AI tools assisted substantially in developing, writing and checking the work. Independent human review is welcome.
Read the paper
Open the published PDF · Download PDF · Original PDF on Zenodo
Supporting materials
Download pr1085_support_v1_0.zip · Original pr1085_support_v1_0.zip on Zenodo
Collaborate on this result
I welcome independent checks of the explicit four-dimensional graph and the geometric comparison for weak attraction.
Authorship and responsibilities would be discussed in relation to substantive contributions. Contact Alec.
Cite this paper
Kriebel, Alec (2026). Robin half-space perturbations: a credited dimension-dependent answer to AIM Problem 1.4. Version 1.0. Zenodo. 10.5281/zenodo.23431279.
Licensing
The deposited work is available under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0.