A counterexample to ideal closure of property-(s) elements in skew braces
Read the paper (PDF) · Download PDF · Supporting ZIP · Zenodo record
Plain-English explanation · Read on this page · Collaboration
Abstract
The elements with property (s) in a skew left brace need not form an additive subgroup, even when the additive group is abelian. On ℤ × ℤ/4ℤ we give an explicit standard semidirect brace whose property-(s) set is ℤ × {0,1}. The element (0,1) has both defining indices equal to two, whereas its additive double has both indices infinite. This answers the unrestricted ideal-closure question of Colazzo negatively. The construction uses known ingredients. We credit an exact overlapping October 2026 preprint and record our earlier September 2026 repository disclosure; historical priority and mutual independence remain unresolved.
The idea in plain English
A skew brace carries two compatible group operations. Property (s) asks for two particular stabilizer intersections to have finite index. This paper gives an explicit example in which an element has the property, but adding it to itself loses the property.
That single failure of addition rules out ideal closure. The calculation is carried out on an infinite brace whose additive group is the familiar product ℤ × ℤ/4ℤ.
The precise result
Write c ⋄ d = c + d + 2cd modulo 4, and set ε(0) = ε(1) = 1 and ε(2) = ε(3) = −1. On B = ℤ × ℤ/4ℤ, use coordinatewise addition and
(n,c) ∘ (m,d) = (n + ε(c)m, c ⋄ d).
This is a left brace with abelian additive group. Its complete property-(s) set is S(B) = ℤ × {0,1}. For x = (0,1), both defining indices are 2. For x + x = (0,2), both indices are infinite. Thus S(B) is not an additive subgroup or an ideal; it also fails λ-invariance.
The property-(s) conventions
With λₐ(b) = −a + a ∘ b and a*b = λₐ(b) − b, put H_z = {g : z*g = 0} ∩ C_(B,+)(z) and K_z = {g : g*z = 0} ∩ C_(B,∘)(z).
Property (s) requires both [(B,+) : H_z] and [(B,∘) : K_z] to be finite. The two indices belong to their respective additive and multiplicative groups.
Why the result holds
The finite factor has a sign character that acts on the infinite integer coordinate. For residues 0 and 1 the relevant subgroups contain all integer coordinates and have finite index. For residues 2 and 3 they force that coordinate to vanish.
Distinct integer translations then give infinitely many cosets. This proves the infinite indices directly.
Scope and limitations
This is an infinite left brace and is not two-sided. It does not contradict the positive ideal-closure theorem for two-sided braces.
Every finite brace has property (s) at every element. Finite quotients alone therefore cannot establish the failure shown here.
Background and prior work
- Colazzo’s Question 1, Oberwolfach Report 9/2023 — The unrestricted ideal-closure question, printed p. 543.
- Colazzo–Ferrara–Trombetti, On derived-indecomposable solutions of the Yang–Baxter equation — Definition 3.7 supplies the conventions; Proposition 3.10 treats two-sided braces.
- Ferudun, The Elements with Property (s) of a Skew Brace Need Not Form an Ideal — This preprint gives exactly the same brace construction and property-(s) set. That exact overlap is credited here.
- Bachiller, Classification of braces of order p³ — An antecedent for the finite brace used in the construction.
- Smoktunowicz–Vendramin, On skew braces — The semidirect construction is standard.
- Dietzel, Braces of order p²q — The same high-bit inversion character appears in an earlier finite cyclic-module family.
- Cascella–Properzi–Van Antwerpen, Finiteness conditions on skew braces and solutions of the Yang–Baxter equation — Earlier finite-conjugacy machinery also explains the set obtained by the direct calculation.
Status and AI use
This is an unrefereed preprint. AI tools were used extensively in the research, proof development, source comparisons and writing. AI review is not conventional human peer review. Alec Kriebel is responsible for the contents.
Read the paper
Supporting materials
Download unchanged native support ZIP · Zenodo original ZIP
The archive includes the editable manuscript and supporting materials.
Collaborate on this result
Useful contributions could include independent mathematical verification, a substantive extension, or work toward a journal submission. Authorship and responsibilities would reflect the contributions actually made.
Cite this paper
Alec Kriebel. (2026). A counterexample to ideal closure of property-(s) elements in skew braces. Zenodo metadata version 1.0.0; no numeric version printed in the manuscript [Preprint]. Zenodo. 10.5281/zenodo.23312287.
Licensing
Zenodo metadata and the support README license the deposit under CC BY 4.0. No distinct code-license term has been established.
Third-party publications retain their own rights.