A characteristic obstruction in higher Koszul homology
Read the paper (PDF) · Download PDF · Supporting ZIP · Zenodo record
Plain-English explanation · Read on this page · Collaboration
Abstract
Over every field of positive characteristic, the free algebra on two degree-one generators is Koszul but has nonzero positive-degree higher Koszul homology. We give an explicit class and the complete cyclic-word calculation. This elementary application of classical tensor-algebra formulas refutes the unrestricted-field equivalence reported in Oberwolfach Report 10/2016. The characteristic-zero converse remains unresolved here.
The idea in plain English
A free algebra consists of words in letters, with multiplication given by joining words. It is Koszul over every field. This note shows that positive characteristic can nevertheless leave nonzero higher Koszul homology.
The calculation groups words by cyclic rotation. Each group contributes a simple map whose scalar is the number of distinct rotations. In characteristic p, that scalar vanishes when p divides the orbit size.
The precise result
Use higher Koszul homology with coefficients in the algebra itself and the fundamental cocycle e_A. Let A = T_k(V), where V has a finite basis of letters, and let n > 0 be the total internal weight.
If char(k) = p > 0, each cyclic orbit O of length-n words with p dividing |O| contributes one copy of k to HK_i^hi(A)[n] for i = 0 and i = 1. No other orbit contributes in those degrees.
In characteristic zero, these positive-weight higher groups vanish. Over every field, higher groups in degrees at least 2 vanish; weight zero contributes k in degree 0 and nothing in degree 1.
For A = k⟨x,y⟩ in characteristic p, the primitive word x^(p−1)y has p distinct rotations. Splitting each rotation into a prefix and its final letter gives a nonzero class z_p = Σ a_j ⊗ v_j in higher degree 1 and weight p.
Why the result holds
For the free algebra, the coefficient complex has only the map b(a ⊗ v) = av − va. On words of a fixed weight this is 1 − ρ, where ρ rotates the final letter to the beginning.
The higher differential goes from rotation invariants to rotation coinvariants. An orbit sum with d distinct words maps to d times a coinvariant generator. Its kernel and cokernel are both one-dimensional exactly when d is zero in the field.
Scope and limitations
The result refutes the literal unrestricted-field equivalence printed in Solotar’s OWR 10/2016 contribution. Berger–Lambre–Solotar’s forward vanishing theorem assumes characteristic zero. This note does not settle the characteristic-zero converse or determine the source authors’ historical intended field scope.
Orbit size counts distinct rotations. The word x^p has a singleton orbit and does not give the stated counterexample; the witness uses x^(p−1)y.
The differential here is Euler cap. Connes’ B goes in the opposite direction and has orbit scalar n/d, whereas Euler cap has scalar d. On the primitive weight-p orbit, Euler cap is zero in characteristic p and B is invertible.
Background and prior work
- Solotar, Koszul Calculus, OWR 10/2016 — The contribution, printed pp. 479–481, states the equivalence without a field-characteristic restriction.
- Berger–Lambre–Solotar, Koszul calculus — The higher-homology definition uses the fundamental cocycle. Theorem 6.4 assumes characteristic zero; Conjecture 6.5 supplies the converse question discussed below.
- Loday–Quillen, Cyclic homology and the Lie algebra homology of matrices — Classical tensor-algebra formulas provide the cyclic invariant/coinvariant calculation and the separate cyclic norm for Connes’ B.
- Goodwillie, Cyclic homology, derivations, and the free loopspace — The Euler cap formula is a classical input to this specialization.
- Ferudun, Higher Koszul Homology of Square-Zero Algebras in Positive Characteristic (v1.0) — This later related preprint treats square-zero algebras k ⊕ V with V² = 0, including k[x,y]/(x,y)². That is a different algebra class from the free algebra T(V) treated here.
Status and AI use
This is an unrefereed preprint. OpenAI tools were used extensively in mathematical development, source comparison and writing. AI review is not conventional human peer review or formal proof-assistant certification. Alec Kriebel is responsible for the contents.
A follow-up on the converse
Over a field of characteristic zero, does HK_0^hi(A) ≅ k together with HK_i^hi(A) = 0 for every i > 0 imply that a connected quadratic algebra A is Koszul? The coefficients are A itself and the differential is induced by the fundamental cocycle e_A.
This is the characteristic-zero converse within Berger–Lambre–Solotar’s Conjecture 6.5. Their characteristic-zero theorem proves the forward direction; the papers discussed here do not resolve this converse.
An affirmative answer would turn this higher-homology acyclicity into a recognition criterion for Koszulness. A counterexample would identify a separate failure of the converse.
Read the paper
Supporting materials
Download unchanged native support ZIP · Zenodo original ZIP
The archive includes the editable manuscript and supporting materials.
Collaborate on this result
Useful contributions could include independent mathematical verification, a substantive extension, or work toward a journal submission. Authorship and responsibilities would reflect the contributions actually made.
Cite this paper
Alec Kriebel. (2026). A characteristic obstruction in higher Koszul homology. Version 1.0.0 [Preprint]. Zenodo. 10.5281/zenodo.23385608.
Licensing
CC BY 4.0 applies to the authored note and supporting authored package.
Underlying cited publications retain their own terms.