Alec Kriebel

A fixed moment separator without a rational normalized sum-of-squares certificate

Read the paper (PDF) · Download PDF · Supporting ZIP · Zenodo record

Plain-English explanation · Read on this page · Collaboration


Abstract

We apply Scheiderer's classical rational quartic, which is a sum of real squares but not rational squares, to the fixed-polynomial certificate question in Oberwolfach Report 14/2023. On the rational unit ball in three variables, an explicit rational degree-four moment vector has mass one and annihilates a rational polynomial p with minimum one. The identity p ∈ 1 + Q_ℝ(g) has a real certificate, whereas p ∉ 1 + Q_ℚ(g), even allowing arbitrary finite multiplier degrees. Here rational certificates mean rational polynomial square factors. The all-degree obstruction is a classical local leading-form argument. The moment matrix is not positive semidefinite, another polynomial gives a rational certificate for the same vector, and every rational rescaling cp, c > 1, has a rational normalized certificate. Thus the example exhibits the phenomenon for one fixed boundary separator; it does not address the companion paper's strict-margin regime.

The idea in plain English

Sum-of-squares certificates prove nonnegativity by writing polynomials as sums of squares, with a constraint multiplier for the unit ball. The coefficients allowed in those square factors matter. In this example, real square factors certify the fixed polynomial at the normalization level one, while rational square factors cannot do so at any finite degree.

The precise result

Let K = {(x,y,z) ∈ ℝ³ : g(x,y,z) = 1 − x² − y² − z² ≥ 0}. Start with Scheiderer’s rational quartic

f = x⁴ + xy³ + y⁴ − 3x²yz − 4xy²z + 2x²z² + xz³ + yz³ + z⁴,

which is a sum of squares over ℝ but not over ℚ. Set p = 1 + f. Its minimum on K is one. For the degree-four moment vector with m₀₀₀ = 1, m₄₀₀ = −1 and every other entry zero, Lm(p) = 0. This mass-one vector therefore has no nonnegative representing measure on K.

Writing QF(g) = {∑aᵢ² + g∑bⱼ² : aᵢ,bⱼ ∈ F[x,y,z]}, with finite sums and no degree bound, the result is

p ∈ 1 + Qℝ(g),   p ∉ 1 + Qℚ(g).

“Rational certificate” here requires rational polynomial square factors. Rational coefficients in multipliers that are sums of real squares are a weaker condition.

Why the result holds

The obstruction comes from the lowest-degree nonzero term at the origin. A hypothetical rational normalized certificate for p would represent f as a sum of rational squares plus g times such a sum. Since g is positive at the origin and f starts in degree four, the degree-four leading form would itself be a rational sum of squares. That contradicts the classical property of f. Higher-degree terms cannot remove this local obstruction.

Scope and limitations

  • The moment matrix is not positive semidefinite: the diagonal entry associated with x² is −1.
  • The polynomial is fixed at its minimum-one boundary. The same moment vector admits a rational normalized certificate using q = 1 + x⁴.
  • For every rational c > 1, cp has a rational normalized certificate on the ball. This statement gives no degree bound.
  • The result concerns rational polynomial square factors for this fixed boundary separator. It makes no general novelty claim and does not settle the companion paper’s strict-margin regime.

Background and prior work

The quartic and its rational-versus-real sum-of-squares obstruction are due to Claus Scheiderer; the local leading-form method is classical. The moment question is recorded by Naldi, reporting joint work with Henrion and Safey El Din, in Oberwolfach Report 14/2023. Their companion manuscript supplies the strict-margin context.

Victoria Powers’ rational positivity theorem accounts for the rational rescaling statement. Earlier work by Henrion, Naldi and Safey El Din and by Naldi and Sinn provides important prior context on rational semidefinite feasibility and infeasibility certificates. The native paper gives the further references and historical qualifications.

Status and AI use

This is an unrefereed, AI-assisted research note. The author is responsible for its contents. The linked native paper and supporting material are the source of record.

The original authored material is available under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International. Third-party material retains its original rights and attribution requirements.

Read the paper

Open PDF · Download PDF · Native Zenodo record

Supporting materials

These are unchanged copies of the native files, in the order shown by the native record.

  1. fixed_moment_separator.pdf — paper PDF. Original file on Zenodo.
  2. fixed_moment_separator_verification.zip — supporting material. Original file on Zenodo.

Collaborate on this result

Researchers interested in independent assessment of this work or a substantive collaboration are welcome to contact Alec. Authorship and responsibilities would be discussed in relation to actual contributions.

Cite this paper

Alec Kriebel. A fixed moment separator without a rational normalized sum-of-squares certificate. Version 1.0, 6 October 2026. Zenodo. 10.5281/zenodo.23196750. Download BibTeX.