Alec Kriebel

Zero Filling and Persistent Free Subgroups of the Figure-Eight Knot

Read the paper (PDF) · Download PDF · Supporting ZIP · Zenodo record

Plain-English explanation · Read on this page · Collaboration


Abstract

The figure-eight knot gives a negative answer to the universal rank-two free-subgroup question printed in Motegi’s 2020 Oberwolfach contribution. It is hyperbolic and has no finite nonmeridional surgery, but no rank-two free subgroup of its knot group injects into every rational filling group. Indeed, zero filling is a torus bundle, so its metabelian fundamental group kills a nontrivial second-derived word in every such free subgroup. We give the short obstruction and verify the no-finite-surgery hypothesis using the classical filling classification. The ingredients are classical; this note records their application and the question’s quantifiers. It does not resolve the search for a positive hyperbolic example. Historical priority cannot be fully cleared, and no firstness claim is made.

The idea in plain English

Dehn filling closes off the boundary of a knot exterior and gives a quotient of its fundamental group. This note asks whether a free subgroup can inject into the filled group for every rational slope. For the figure-eight knot, zero filling already rules that out.

The precise result

The figure-eight knot is hyperbolic, and every rational nonmeridional filling has infinite fundamental group. Nevertheless, if G is its knot group, H ≤ G is isomorphic to the free group F2, and q0 is the homomorphism induced by zero filling, then

H ∩ ker(q0) ≠ {1}.

Thus no such subgroup injects into every rational filling group. This gives a negative answer to the universal affirmative reading of the question printed on p.493 of Motegi’s 2020 Oberwolfach contribution. Rational slopes here include zero and exclude the meridian at infinity.

Why the result holds

Zero surgery on the figure-eight knot is a torus bundle over the circle. Its fundamental group has an abelian normal subgroup ℤ2 and an abelian quotient ℤ. It is therefore metabelian: commutators of commutators are trivial.

A free group on two generators has nontrivial commutators of commutators. The note exhibits one explicitly. Every homomorphism from that free group to the zero-filling group kills this word, so injectivity fails for every rank-two free subgroup, regardless of its position in the knot group.

The classical exceptional-filling classification supplies the other hypothesis: all rational fillings have infinite fundamental group. The argument treats the nine exceptional slopes as well as the hyperbolic fillings.

Scope and limitations

This counterexample concerns a requirement to survive every rational filling, including zero. It leaves the separate search for a positive hyperbolic example unresolved and does not settle a version of the question that permits discarding finitely many slopes. Injectivity into a product of filling groups would be a different, weaker condition.

The topology and the metabelian group law are classical. Historical priority cannot be fully cleared; the note makes no claim of firstness, new topological ingredients or continued open status. The published manuscript describes the limits of its literature inspection.

Background and prior work

Status and AI use

Unrefereed preprint. AI tools assisted in developing, writing and checking the work. Independent human review is welcome.

Read the paper

Open the published PDF · Download PDF · Original PDF on Zenodo

Supporting materials

Download verification_package.zip · Original supporting ZIP on Zenodo

Collaborate on this result

I welcome researchers in three-manifold topology or geometric group theory who would like to independently check the zero-filling obstruction, its precise relation to the printed question, or its relationship with earlier persistent-subgroup results. Careful identification of an earlier explicit statement would improve the attribution. I am open to substantive collaboration on a revised manuscript and journal submission.

Authorship and responsibilities would be discussed in relation to the contributions made. Contact Alec.

Cite this paper

Kriebel, Alec (2026). Zero Filling and Persistent Free Subgroups of the Figure-Eight Knot. Version 1.0. Zenodo. 10.5281/zenodo.23386475.

Download BibTeX

Licensing

The deposited work is available under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0.