A first-order obstruction to Habiro's rank interpolation
Rank interpolation asks for one expression recovering the standard unified quantum invariant of a homology sphere at every matrix size. For the ordinary integral completion displayed in Ohtsuki’s Conjecture 7.30, this note gives a negative answer whenever the sphere has nonzero Casson invariant. A finite quotient already forces a relation that the classical first-coefficient formula violates.
Read the paper
Open the original PDF · Download the PDF · Zenodo record and DOI · BibTeX
The original PDF is unchanged. The manuscript and native record both identify version 1.0 and 16 October 2026; the deposit was created that day at 20:11 UTC.
The literal completion and the theorem
The coefficient ring is the ordinary integral Habiro ring, and the rank variable is completed using the displayed products:
R = lim←m ℤ[q, q−1] / (∏j=1m (qj − 1)).
Em(t) = ∏j=1m (t − qj), and S = lim←m R[t] / (Em(t)).
The transition maps are quotient maps. For F in S, evaluation at t = qn uses any coordinate m ≥ n. Here n is the matrix size for sln; its Lie rank is n − 1. All sizes use the same parameter q and the standard invariant normalization, with I1(M) assigned the value 1.
For every integral homology 3-sphere M with nonzero Casson invariant, there is no FM in S satisfying FM(qn) = Islₙ(M) for all integers n ≥ 2 and FM(q) = 1. The Casson–Walker invariant λC is taken in Lê’s stated Lescop normalization. This is an obstruction to the literal displayed ordinary completion and normalization.
A contradiction in the first coefficient
Work only to first order in x = q − 1, so x² = 0. The substitutions q = 1 + x and q−1 = 1 − x define a map from R to ℤ[x]/(x²). In the third interpolation coordinate, a representative of F is a polynomial a + bt + ct². Its first coefficient after substituting t = qn has the form A + nB: it is affine, or a straight line, in n.
Write those first coefficients as vn. At sizes 1, 2 and 3, any interpolating F must therefore satisfy
v3 − 2v2 + v1 = 0.
The established quantum-invariant coefficient is instead
vn = n(n² − 1)λC(M), for n ≥ 2.
The common type-A convention has roots of squared length 2 and q = v² = exp(h). Replacing h with q − 1 leaves the first coefficient unchanged; no rank-dependent rescaling is introduced. Since the assigned size-1 invariant is 1, its first coefficient is zero. Sizes 1, 2 and 3 then give a second difference of 12λC(M), which cannot vanish when λC(M) ≠ 0. The argument uses finite coefficient and interpolation quotients, without Taylor injectivity or differentiation of an infinite sum.
Omitting size 1 does not remove the obstruction: sizes 2, 3 and 4 give the incompatible second difference 18λC(M).
An explicit oriented witness
Take the Poincaré homology sphere obtained by −1 surgery on the left-handed trefoil. The source’s unified series has constant term 1 and first coefficient −6 at size 2; its remaining terms contribute nothing in the fixed first-order quotient. The coefficient formula fixes λC = −1 in the stated convention.
| Matrix size n | First coefficient vn |
|---|---|
| 1 | 0 |
| 2 | −6 |
| 3 | −24 |
The second difference is −24 − 2(−6) + 0 = −12, giving the concrete contradiction.
Scope and established inputs
This is a credited deduction from established quantum-invariant results and finite algebra. Lê’s 2000 coefficient formula supplies the first coefficient, and Habiro–Lê’s 2016 unification theorem and Taylor identification connect it to the standard unified invariants. The classical cubic type-A behavior is already explicit in Lê–Murakami–Ohtsuki (1998) and Garoufalidis–Lê–Mariño (2008). The sphere-series locator in Habiro’s work refers specifically to arXiv:math/0605314v1, §16.1, equation (16.1).
The result gives no existence criterion when λC(M) = 0 and proposes no corrected formulation. Allowing poles in q − 1, changing the completion or introducing rank-dependent normalization changes the question. Fixed-Lie unification, link-interpolation stability and enlarged knot-color Newton rings, including the works of Beliakova–Gorsky, Fang–Zhou and Fang cited in the manuscript, do not by themselves assert this S-valued homology-sphere interpolation.
No novelty, firstness, present-openness or exhaustive absence-of-earlier-resolution claim is made. Ohtsuki’s collection has volume year 2002; its publisher record gives release on 1 June 2004. Those are different bibliographic dates.
Original manuscript abstract
The rank completion printed in Ohtsuki's Conjecture 7.30 cannot interpolate the standard unified sl_n invariants of an integral homology sphere with nonzero Casson invariant. A finite quotient forces its first Taylor coefficients to be affine in n, contrary to the classical cubic coefficient formula. The specified Poincaré sphere gives the incompatible values 0,−6,−24. This is a negative answer to the literal displayed statement, obtained from established quantum-invariant results.
Original files and citation
The original files are available here and from Zenodo, in the record’s order:
- habiro-rank-interpolation-v1.0.pdf (60,591 bytes) · Zenodo original PDF
- habiro-rank-interpolation-verification-v1.0.zip (1,660,004 bytes) · Zenodo original ZIP
Kriebel, Alec. A first-order obstruction to Habiro's rank interpolation. Version 1.0, 16 October 2026. doi:10.5281/zenodo.23425412. Download BibTeX.
The authored note and verification materials, including authored code, use Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International. Third-party works and retained historical material keep their original attribution and rights.
Status and collaboration
Extensive AI tools assisted solving, source research, computation, writing and adversarial review. This preprint has undergone internal AI-assisted proof review. It is unrefereed; no independent human peer review, journal acceptance or formal proof-assistant certification is asserted. The written proof uses established topology results; finite arithmetic controls do not computationally certify those inputs.
Independent verification, substantive mathematical extensions and journal work would be useful contributions. Collaboration and any authorship would reflect actual scholarly contributions.