Alec Kriebel

The vertex centroid of focal antipedals of even elliptic billiards

Read the paper (PDF) · Download PDF · Supporting ZIP · Zenodo record

Plain-English explanation · Read on this page · Collaboration


Abstract

For a periodic billiard in an ellipse with a strictly nested confocal elliptical caustic and even least period, we prove that the unweighted vertex centroids of the original antipedals about the center and the two foci are constant throughout its Poncelet family. The central centroid is zero; an explicit focal coefficient depends only on the axes, caustic parameter, period and perimeter. This answers invariant k405 as posed without proof by Reznik, Garcia and Koiller. The proof uses opposite edges, an elementary finite circle action, and perimeter stationarity. Ferudun's subsequent deposited note states the same theorem and coefficient and uses the same pair-and-moment mechanism; we explicitly credit that overlap and make no absolute priority or independent-discovery claim.

The idea in plain English

Start an even-period elliptic billiard orbit at a different point. The polygon moves, but the average of the vertices of its focal antipedal stays fixed. The paper gives that average exactly.

Choose the center or a focus as a pole. For each billiard edge, draw the full line through each endpoint perpendicular to the segment joining that endpoint to the pole. The intersection of those two lines is an antipedal vertex. The centroid here is the ordinary, unweighted mean of these vertices.

The construction uses the original billiard polygon. It does not use the outer tangent polygon, pedal feet or an area centroid.

The exact centroid formula

Let the outer ellipse have semiaxes a > b > 0, with c = √(a2 − b2) and foci Fσ = (σc, 0), σ = ±1. The confocal elliptical caustic is strictly nested:

x2/(a2 − λ) + y2/(b2 − λ) = 1,   0 < λ < b2.

Let N be the even least period and L the common perimeter of the Poncelet family. Define

K = a2b2 − λc2,
H = (a2/c2)(1 − bL/(2a√λ N)).

Then the center-pole centroid is zero, and the focal centroids are

𝒞O = (0, 0),
𝒞Fσ = (σc[−1 + KH/(a2(b2 − λ))], 0).

These quantities are independent of the starting point within the family. The theorem includes primitive star polygons and either traversal orientation.

Why the centroid is fixed

For even least period, opposite billiard vertices are negatives of one another. Pairing their edges makes the center-pole antipedal intersections cancel. At a focus, the opposite-edge calculation reduces the centroid to two chord moments.

Perimeter stationarity makes one moment constant and the other zero. Substituting those moments into the pair identity gives the displayed focal coefficient. The proof supplies the finite circle-action argument needed for the central symmetry.

Scope and limitations

Strict nesting, a nondegenerate confocal elliptical caustic and even least period are required. An odd-period polygon repeated twice still has odd least period. The note supplies a repeated-triangle example showing this distinction.

Two-bounce orbits, hyperbolic caustics and limiting degenerate caustics are outside the statement. In a circle, the foci coincide with the center and central symmetry gives zero; the formula containing 1/c2 is not used.

Background and prior work

Reznik, Garcia and Koiller posed invariant k405 without a proof or value in Fifty New Invariants of N-Periodics in the Elliptic Billiard (2021), Table 5, and the corresponding 2020 author manuscript. Classical confocal-billiard closure and conservation results are credited to sources including Stachel and Bialy and Tabachnikov. Related pedal-centroid and harmonic results, together with the skew-hodograph correspondence discussed by Gutkin and Tabachnikov, provide another route once the target-specific pair identity is inserted.

A. Ferudun’s Original Antipedal Centroids in Elliptic Billiards, version 1.0, states the same scoped theorem and explicit coefficient and uses the same opposite-edge pair-and-moment mechanism.

Status and AI use

Unrefereed preprint. AI tools assisted substantially in developing, writing and checking the work. Independent human review is welcome.

Read the paper

Open the published PDF · Download PDF · Original PDF on Zenodo

Supporting materials

Download antipedal_centroids_support.zip · Original support archive on Zenodo

Collaborate on this result

I welcome researchers in elliptic billiards or classical geometry who would like to independently check the opposite-edge identity and focal coefficient, compare the proof with the overlapping formulation and earlier centroid results, or develop a revised manuscript for journal submission.

Authorship and responsibilities would be discussed in relation to substantive contributions. Contact Alec.

Cite this paper

Kriebel, Alec (2026). The vertex centroid of focal antipedals of even elliptic billiards. Version 1.0. Zenodo. 10.5281/zenodo.23220043.

Download BibTeX

Licensing

The deposited work is available under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0.