Alec Kriebel

Equal dilatations deep in the Johnson filtration: a convex-core proof

Read the paper (PDF) · Download PDF · Supporting ZIP · Zenodo record

Plain-English explanation · Read on this page · Collaboration


Abstract

Farb asked whether the pseudo-Anosov dilatation spectrum of a fixed deep Johnson-filtration term has bounded multiplicity, counted using ambient mapping-class conjugacy. Ferudun has recorded a negative answer, including this scope. We give an alternative proof using a compact convex core. For every fixed closed genus g ≥ 2, fixed finite depth k ≥ 3, and N, there are N pairwise nonconjugate elements of I_g(k) in Mod_g with one common pseudo-Anosov dilatation. Explicit commutators produce hyperbolic elements at the prescribed depth; high powers give a Schottky subgroup. A compact-core argument uniformly bounds fusion of its conjugacy classes in any discrete Fuchsian overgroup. Horowitz's universal trace families then give the result. The argument does not require an arithmetic description of the full disk stabilizer. No priority or novelty claim is made.

The idea in plain English

A pseudo-Anosov mapping class stretches a surface by a factor called its dilatation. Deep Johnson-filtration terms constrain how the mapping class acts on nilpotent quotients of the surface group. Even with the genus and one finite depth fixed, a common stretching factor can occur in arbitrarily many classes that remain distinct under conjugation in the full mapping class group.

The precise result

Fix a closed oriented surface of genus g ≥ 2 and a finite Johnson depth k ≥ 3. For every integer N ≥ 1, there are pseudo-Anosov elements f₁,…,fN in Ig(k) with the same dilatation, pairwise nonconjugate in the full orientation-preserving mapping class group Modg.

Thus the multiplicity of the dilatation spectrum in that fixed term is unbounded. A class is counted when it has a representative in Ig(k); the conjugators may belong to all of Modg. The paper uses the convention Ig(1) = the Torelli group.

Why the result holds

Explicit commutators of separating twists produce hyperbolic derivatives at the prescribed depth. Suitable powers generate a free rank-two subgroup whose image has a compact convex core.

Compactness gives a uniform bound on how many conjugacy classes in this subgroup can merge into one class in a discrete Fuchsian overgroup. The invariant Teichmüller disk connects that bound to ambient mapping-class conjugacy. Horowitz’s universal equal-trace families then provide enough subgroup classes to leave arbitrarily many distinct ambient classes at a common dilatation.

The argument needs injectivity on the chosen free subgroup, rather than an arithmetic description or injectivity of the full disk stabilizer.

Scope and limitations

  • The genus and one finite depth are fixed. The result includes genus two and each finite k ≥ 3 separately.
  • The common dilatation may depend on N. Infinite multiplicity at a single fixed value is not asserted.
  • Powers are allowed. Ambient primitivity, simple-length multiplicity and the intersection of all Johnson terms are outside the statement.
  • The note gives an alternative proof of an earlier result. It makes no claim of a new existence theorem, a new mechanism, first priority or current worldwide openness.

Background and prior work

The multiplicity question is Farb’s Question 7.6. A. Ferudun’s fixed version 1.0 preprint of 11 October 2026, Theorem 1.1, already contains this result and stronger conclusions, including comparison up to inversion and in the extended mapping class group. This earlier theorem is explicitly credited.

The proof uses Horowitz’s universal trace families, the disk and derivative results stated by Leininger, and the separating filling-pair construction in Aougab and Taylor. Anderson’s survey provides earlier context for passing from subgroup conjugacy to ambient conjugacy.

Status and AI use

This is an unrefereed, AI-assisted research note. The author is responsible for its contents. The linked native paper and supporting material are the source of record.

The native record is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International. Cited works retain their own rights. No separate code license is asserted here.

Read the paper

Open PDF · Download PDF · Native Zenodo record

Supporting materials

These are unchanged copies of the native files, in the order shown by the native record.

  1. Johnson_Filtration_Multiplicity_Note_v1.0.pdf — paper PDF. Original file on Zenodo.
  2. Johnson_Filtration_Multiplicity_Verification_v1.0.zip — supporting material. Original file on Zenodo.

Collaborate on this result

Researchers interested in independently assessing the convex-core argument or discussing a substantive collaboration are welcome to contact Alec. Authorship and responsibilities would be discussed in relation to actual contributions.

Cite this paper

Alec Kriebel. Equal dilatations deep in the Johnson filtration: a convex-core proof. Version 1.0, 17 October 2026. Zenodo. 10.5281/zenodo.23442218. Download BibTeX.