Unbounded Godbillon–Vey numbers on a fixed hyperbolic manifold
A foliation divides a three-manifold into surfaces called leaves. Its Godbillon–Vey number measures a form of transverse twisting. This note assembles classical ingredients to make that number arbitrarily large on one fixed hyperbolic manifold, while a single closed curve continues to cross every leaf.
Read the manuscript
Open the original PDF · Download PDF · BibTeX · Zenodo record
The PDF is unchanged. Its printed date is 13 October 2026, with no numeric version printed. Version 1.0 is native record metadata; the record was created on 14 October 2026 (UTC). Use the direct link if the embedded reader is unavailable.
Original abstract
Classical compact-support suspension theory yields a smooth foliated surface-times-interval with product endpoint collars and nonzero Godbillon–Vey integral. We place arbitrarily many copies inside one fixed pseudo-Anosov mapping torus. One embedded closed transversal meets every leaf, and the Godbillon–Vey numbers grow linearly with the number of copies. This gives a negative answer to the unrestricted volume-bound question printed as Question 10.6 in Calegari’s 2002 manuscript. The construction uses classical ingredients; historical priority of this specific consequence remains unestablished.
One manifold, unbounded numbers
There exist a closed connected oriented hyperbolic three-manifold M, a constant a > 0, and an embedded smooth circle γ such that, for every finite integer N ≥ 1, M has a smooth cooriented taut foliation FN with ordinary Godbillon–Vey number
gv(FN) = ∫M ηN ∧ dηN = Na, where dαN = αN ∧ ηN.
The same γ is positively transverse to every FN and meets every leaf. This is the one-circle meaning of tautness used here. The manifold, circle, constant and hyperbolic metric are chosen before N varies. The metric’s volume stays fixed, so no finite bound determined solely by that volume can bound these numbers or their absolute values.
How the construction works
The starting piece is a smooth foliated surface-times-interval block with positive ordinary Godbillon–Vey integral a. Classical Mather–Thurston theory, with the suspension compatibility recorded by Tsuboi, supplies this piece. Near both interval endpoints it is exactly a product. Every leaf meets the interval above any chosen point of the surface.
The ambient space is a mapping torus: the two ends of a surface-times-interval are joined by a smooth representative of a pseudo-Anosov mapping class. Thurston’s hyperbolization theorem makes this one closed manifold hyperbolic. A representative fixing a small disk provides a point whose vertical interval closes into the embedded circle γ. The mapping class is pseudo-Anosov; its disk-fixed representative need not be a pseudo-Anosov normal form.
For each finite N, compress N copies of the block into separate interior slabs. Exact product collars make the foliations and defining forms join smoothly, without changing the seam. Each compressed block retains its integral a; the intervening product regions contribute zero, giving Na. Block leaves meet γ by the suspension property, and the remaining product leaves meet it too.
Scope and credit
The target is the literal unrestricted volume question, Calegari’s 2002 manuscript, Question 10.6 at printed page 25. Compact leaves are allowed. The different Question 13.1 assumes minimal taut foliations and asks about a same-sign Godbillon–Vey form; this construction does not answer it. The final 2003 chapter was not compared, so its citation does not certify identical wording.
Only finite stacks are used. Derivatives may grow with N; no uniform regularity bound or infinite-stack limit is asserted. The theorem concerns one suitable manifold, and gives no explicit numerical holonomy representation or certified hyperbolic metric.
The result is a credited consequence of classical constructions. Mather–Thurston and Tsuboi supply the suspension input; Gabai documents interval-bundle replacement; Penner and Fathi supply the pseudo-Anosov twist construction; Thurston supplies hyperbolization. Historical firstness, guaranteed novelty and present global literature status remain unestablished.
Original files and citation
The original assets are provided in the native record’s order:
- Verification package (ZIP, 233,634 bytes) · Zenodo original
- Manuscript (PDF, 62,381 bytes) · Zenodo original
- Standalone LaTeX (11,166 bytes) · Zenodo original
Kriebel, Alec. Unbounded Godbillon–Vey numbers on a fixed hyperbolic manifold. 13 October 2026. Zenodo, version 1.0. doi:10.5281/zenodo.23357329. Download BibTeX.
The record licenses its original deposited material under CC BY 4.0. Cited third-party works retain their own rights.
References
- D. Calegari, Problems in foliations and laminations of 3-manifolds, 2002 manuscript, Question 10.6. Published citation: Proc. Sympos. Pure Math. 71 (2003), 297–335, DOI.
- T. Tsuboi, On 2-cycles of B Diff(S¹) which are represented by foliated S¹-bundles over T², Ann. Inst. Fourier 31(2) (1981), 1–59. DOI.
- D. Gabai, Taut foliations of 3-manifolds and suspensions of S¹, Ann. Inst. Fourier 42(1–2) (1992), 193–208, Operation 2.1.3. DOI.
- R. C. Penner, A construction of pseudo-Anosov homeomorphisms, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 310(1) (1988), 179–197, Theorem 3.1. DOI.
- A. Fathi, Démonstration d’un théorème de Penner sur la composition des twists de Dehn, Bull. Soc. Math. France 120(4) (1992), 467–484.
- W. P. Thurston, Hyperbolic structures on 3-manifolds, II: Surface groups and 3-manifolds which fiber over the circle, August 1986 preprint, January 1998 eprint. arXiv:math/9801045v1.
Status and collaboration
AI tools were used extensively in development, drafting, source checking, reproduction and review. This preprint is unrefereed; internal AI-assisted checks are not conventional human peer review, journal acceptance or formal proof certification.
Independent verification, substantive extensions and journal preparation would be useful contributions. Collaboration and authorship would be based on actual contributions.