A qualitative pre-Schwarzian improvement for real schlicht functions
A schlicht function is a holomorphic map that is one-to-one throughout the unit disk. Requiring its Taylor coefficients to be real forces reflection symmetry. This note uses that symmetry to improve a classical bound on the derivative quotient f″/f′ at each fixed nonreal point.
The improvement works for every eligible function at that point: there is one smaller bound shared by the whole class. The proof establishes the existence of a positive gap. Its size depends on the evaluation point.
Open the original PDF (5 pages) · Download PDF · Original files · BibTeX · DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23384924
The fixed-point theorem
Let 𝔻={z∈ℂ:|z|<1}. The class Sℝ consists of all holomorphic injections of the entire disk into ℂ with f(0)=0, f′(0)=1 and real Taylor coefficients. Equivalently, f(z̄)=f(z)̄. These functions have nonvanishing derivative, so define
Pf(z)=f″(z)/f′(z),
Af(z)=(1−|z|²)Pf(z)−2z̄,
M(z)=maxf∈Sℝ|Af(z)|.
The classical centered estimate is |Af(z)|≤4. The note proves that the maximum M(z) exists and gives the following exact qualitative conclusion.
| Evaluation set | Conclusion for the entire class Sℝ |
|---|---|
| A fixed nonreal point z∈𝔻 | M(z)<4; one ε(z)=4−M(z)>0 works for every f. |
| The real diameter −1<x<1 | M(x)=4. |
| Any nonempty compact K⊂𝔻∖ℝ | One εK>0 gives |Af(z)|≤4−εK for every f and every z∈K. |
The fixed-point question in Hayman–Lingham Problem 6.86 uses the equivalent estimate
|zPf(z)−2|z|²/(1−|z|²)| ≤ 4|z|/(1−|z|²).
At a fixed nonreal z its right side can therefore be reduced to (4−ε(z))|z|/(1−|z|²). At z=0 this original expression is identically zero, whereas the auxiliary Af(0)=f″(0) need not vanish. At nonzero real points, the two real Koebe functions give opposite endpoints of the classical disk, so its radius cannot be reduced even if its center is moved.
The contribution and its classical ingredients
The contribution is a qualitative fixed-point answer, with the real-axis exception, to Problem 6.86 in Hayman and Lingham's 2018 collection. It combines classical second-coefficient equality, reflection symmetry of the equality domains and compactness to turn strictness for individual functions into a strict bound for the whole class.
The classical estimate and these methods are credited to the existing theory. The collection's dated progress report supplies historical context. The note claims neither historical firstness, present openness, a new general method nor exhaustive priority clearance.
Koepf's 1986 extreme-point work concerns a linear-functional framework and does not directly optimize f″/f′. Rodemich's 1979 argument estimate for (1−z²)f′ and Aleksandrov–Popova's 1973 nonlinear first-jet estimates are related earlier results. Jenkins's 1960 derivative estimates are also relevant. Exact overlap with the Jenkins and Aleksandrov–Popova results remains unverified; the proof here is self-contained.
Why real symmetry creates a gap
The normalized Koebe transform converts equality |Af(z)|=4 into the classical equality case |a₂|=2 for a normalized univalent function. That case is a Koebe rotation. Undoing the transform shows that the image of the original function is the plane with one ray removed.
For a function with real coefficients, the omitted ray must be invariant under reflection in the real axis. Its endpoint and direction are therefore real. Normalization then leaves exactly the two real Koebe maps
k+(z)=z/(1−z)², k−(z)=z/(1+z)².
Their values satisfy
|Ak₊(z)|²=|Ak₋(z)|²=16−48(Im z)²/|1−z²|².
This is strictly below 16 off the real axis. On the real diameter Ak₊(x)=4 and Ak₋(x)=−4.
Individual strictness still allows the possibility of a sequence approaching 4. Compactness closes that gap: normalized univalent functions form a compact family under locally uniform convergence, and the real-coefficient condition is closed. Derivative convergence makes |Af(z)| jointly continuous at interior points. The maximum is attained, both at a fixed point and over the product with a compact nonreal set, so equality exclusion gives the stated uniform gaps.
A one-variable reduction and exact lower bounds
Real disk automorphisms and reflection preserve the class and reduce M(z) to the single parameter
δ(z)=|Im z|/|1−z²|, 0≤δ<½.
Every nonreal point is equivalent to it or −it for a unique 0<t<1, with δ=t/(1+t²). The real Koebe maps and the globally univalent function h(z)=z/(1−z²), transported by the real automorphisms, give
max{4√(1−3δ²), 8δ} ≤ M(z) < 4 (Im z≠0).
These are lower bounds. Their branches cross at δ=1/√7. At z=i/2 the squared Koebe value is 208/25 while |Ah(i/2)|²=256/25, so the real Koebe pair cannot alone supply the maximizers there. The note determines no sharp formula for M, explicit upper-gap formula, general extremizers or full variability region.
There is no single positive gap on all nonreal points. Approaching an interior real point through nonreal points sends the Koebe lower bound to 4. Along z=it→i, the second lower bound tends to 4. Both paths escape every compact nonreal set covered by a fixed εK. Near the boundary endpoints ±1, merely having Im z→0 does not imply δ→0.
Original manuscript abstract
For normalized univalent functions with real Taylor coefficients, the classical centered pre-Schwarzian disk can be strictly shrunk at every fixed nonreal point, uniformly over the class. On the real diameter its classical radius remains sharp. We prove this qualitative answer to Hayman–Lingham Problem 6.86 by combining classical coefficient equality, reflection symmetry of the equality domains, and compactness. The gap is uniform on compact nonreal sets. No explicit upper-gap formula or sharp radius is determined. The proof uses classical methods, and no historical firstness is claimed.
Original files and citation
The two unchanged native files appear in their original Zenodo order. The verification archive includes the manuscript source, original research candidate and scope clarification, analytic and source audits, exact algebraic controls and explicitly uncertified numerical replays. Full third-party source scans are excluded.
- Manuscript PDF — real_schlicht_preschwarzian.pdf · Zenodo original
- Source and verification archive — real_schlicht_verification.zip · Zenodo original
Kriebel, Alec (15 October 2026). A qualitative pre-Schwarzian improvement for real schlicht functions (Version 1.0, native record metadata) [Preprint]. Zenodo. 10.5281/zenodo.23384924. Download BibTeX · Native record.
The manuscript prints 15 October 2026 and no numeric version. The native record declares that date and metadata version 1.0. Its creation and modification timestamps both fall on 15 October 2026.
The native record specifies CC BY 4.0. Referenced third-party papers and software retain their own rights.
Main references
- W. K. Hayman and E. F. Lingham, Research Problems in Function Theory (New Edition), 2018 v2, Chapter 6, printed pages 114 and 147, Problem 6.86.
- W. K. Hayman, Multivalent Functions, Cambridge Tracts in Mathematics and Mathematical Physics 48, Cambridge University Press, 1958.
- W. Koepf, On nonvanishing univalent functions with real coefficients, Mathematische Zeitschrift 192 (1986), 575–579, Section 4.
- E. Rodemich, An inequality for univalent functions with real coefficients, Notices of the American Mathematical Society 26 (January 1979), abstract 763-30-11, A-68. Archived publisher scan.
- J. A. Jenkins, On univalent functions with real coefficients, Annals of Mathematics 71 (1960), 1–15; and The general coefficient theorem and certain applications, Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society 68 (1962), 1–9.
- I. A. Aleksandrov and G. A. Popova, Extremal properties of univalent holomorphic functions with real coefficients, Sibirsk. Mat. Zh. 14 (1973), 915–926; English translation, Siberian Mathematical Journal 14 (1973), 635–643.
Read the manuscript
Open PDF in a full window · Download PDF · Original PDF on Zenodo
Research status and contributions
AI tools were used extensively in developing the argument, checking sources and computations, adversarial verification and writing. Alec Kriebel is responsible for the claims and artifacts. This is an unrefereed preprint; internal AI reviews do not constitute independent human peer review or formal verification. Exact algebraic controls supplement the written analytic proof. The archived exploratory numerical values are uncertified and play no role in that proof.
Researchers interested in independent verification, substantial mathematical extensions, or developing a revised manuscript for journal submission are welcome to contribute. Authorship and acknowledgments depend on the substantive work actually contributed; endorsement alone does not confer authorship.