Independent initial mathematical position, before reading author proof, original historical audits, peer or root conclusions for PR786.
Exact selected question: for a partition lambda, is simple head of the Young module equivalent to existence of at least one rank n >= length(lambda) where its indecomposable injective polynomial module is projective? Selected prior_research is the empty object. The dated open-status metadata is not a verified present status.
Initial skepticism: the existential rank is crucial; one-row partitions cannot refute it because rank1 is semisimple. Any claimed rank2 obstruction must propagate to every larger rank using a valid truncation/tilting or other mechanism. All-ranks cannot be inferred merely from computations up to n=r. Algebraic-group polynomial representations over an algebraically closed field must not be identified with representations of finite GL_n(F_p).
Potential independent mechanism: natural permutation modules for S_r when p divides r have two-dimensional centralizer span I,J with J^2=rJ=0, hence local endomorphism ring and indecomposability. Their augmentation/fixed-line composition can give a simple trivial head. This suggests examining lambda=(r-1,1), but is not a conclusion about the candidate (not yet read). On the polynomial side, symmetric-power tensor modules S^{r-1}(V) tensor V are natural injective candidates; their coefficient operators and weight graphs can test self-duality/head versus socle. Low degrees r=p or2p can have projective rank2 cases, so they are danger controls; Frobenius digit/binomial vanishings require exact treatment. r=p(p+1) is a plausible boundary to probe independently, not an asserted counterexample.
Success criteria: identify the actual partition and hypotheses; prove simple Young head with correct labeling; identify the actual I_n(lambda), not merely a summand; establish nonprojectivity for every permitted n; prove any self-duality/tilting/truncation implications used; calculate unipotent coefficients symbolically for all odd primes; verify finite controls without mistaking finite field samples for algebraic-group invariance. Check actual OWR2009 and De Visscher–Donkin mathematical statements and quantifiers. Status initially undecided.
Session independence: same worker reused after new-worker creation failed ENOSPC. No PR786 author proof, historical mathematical audits, peer or root mathematical conclusion has been read. Intake eligibility metadata necessarily disclosed claimed_solved, odd-characteristic counterexamples and an all-ranks claim. No outcome is accepted as an assumption.
